FR

GB

VBO event on 23 October 2026 at Domaine Yvon Moussy: Copper regulations and alternatives

Share this post:

An overview of water issues and water quality in the Congy area

Over 95 per cent of the water supplied to the municipality is drawn from two boreholes. This resource is classified as ‘sensitive’ by the Water Agency, which led to a study of the catchment area to assess land use and develop an action plan drawn up in collaboration with the various local stakeholders (farmers, private individuals, businesses, local authorities, etc.). These measures, approved to improve the protection of the water resource, are subsequently implemented on a voluntary basis by the stakeholders.

Prior to 2021, there were no water quality concerns in the area. An analysis by the Regional Health Agency (ARS), carried out after that date and based on the agency’s new criteria, subsequently detected metabolites of plant protection products at levels of concern. The main metabolite found at high levels is a herbicide that was used in beet cultivation and was banned around 2018. The water was therefore classified as non-compliant, requiring the preparation of a report setting out measures to be taken – including water treatment – in order to continue abstracting the resource. Another issue in the area is the nitrate content of the water. Monitoring of this parameter has been stepped up, as the water resource is considered vulnerable in relation to this second parameter.

The issue of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS, also known as ‘forever chemicals’) was raised following a question from a winegrower present at the meeting. None of the 20 PFAS analysed were detected in the water tests carried out.

The role of the ARS was clarified. The recommendations it provides are only ad hoc and relate solely to diffuse pollution linked to plant health issues in our case. The area-specific regulations that may be introduced mainly concern organic soil amendments, and in particular health issues relating to water quality. The agency merely offers incentives, with voluntary measures to be implemented in catchment areas. Mention was made of the financial incentive introduced as part of a scheme to set aside plots of land, subject to compliance with a set of specifications (particularly regarding ground cover), in certain catchment areas.

 

Copper and water quality

There are no non-compliance issues relating to this heavy metal within the Congy catchment area. The heavy metals detected originate mainly from the distribution network and pipes (lead and nickel). 

The issue of copper mobility in soils was also clarified. It was explained that copper is not very mobile in soils; it tends mainly to accumulate in the upper soil horizons, binding with organic matter in particular. It is only under certain soil conditions, combined with a specific precipitation pattern, that copper can be leached and carried away in water. It was emphasised that surface runoff can carry copper away in the case of bare soil, and that tillage tends to bury the copper in deeper soil layers.

 

A reminder of the regulations governing the use of copper, and developments in recent months

This discussion provided an opportunity to remind the audience of recent developments, including some key dates and decisions.

July 2025: ANSES decisions regarding the non-renewal of authorisation for several commercial products, and the introduction of stricter regulations governing the use of Champflo and Héliocuivre.

 

A reminder of the solutions still available on the market (number, conditions of use), and further details regarding the re-authorisation processes currently underway in Italy. Similarly, it was emphasised that ANSES might apply a different interpretation of the rules governing the use of copper-based products pending re-authorisation by the Italian Ministry of Health.

An update on court rulings was also provided, with the Council of State’s decision still pending following a referral by ANSES to challenge the ruling of the Melun Administrative Court concerning the firm COSACO.

Antonin also pointed out that positive developments could be on the horizon, following the work carried out by the FNAB and the establishment of a task force, including, in particular, the possible submission to ANSES of dossiers that have been completed and revised by the companies for products whose marketing authorisations have been withdrawn.

 

An important point was raised: that of averaging, with the new rules on the use of Champflo and Heliocuivre. Averaging is still possible for the time being, except for Spe1 products, for which the total applied over the growing season must not exceed 4 kg/ha/year. Thus, the total amount of copper applied may still exceed 4 kg/ha on an ad hoc basis and be averaged over 7 years, except for Spe1 products. Using an Spe1 product during the growing season still allows for averaging.

 

Overall, the various issues surrounding copper were addressed and clarified:

– the pending Italian decisions on re-registrations

– the continuation of averaging, and the associated conditions

– the uncertain status of copper, given its European status as a candidate for substitution and its authorisation period expiring in 2029

– the issue surrounding the role of private auditors (Veritas, Ecocert, etc.) and government inspections regarding the blending and use of products

– the destruction of batches with a use-by date expiring in January 2027

 

Reminders regarding spray quality

The aim of this brief point was to reiterate that, regardless of the solution used, spray application is a factor that must be controlled and taken into account. Regularly checking and maintaining equipment helps to improve the use and application of pest control solutions.

The issue of treating crops at night (at the end of the day or early in the morning) was raised for several reasons:

– regulations concerning copper and treatments during flowering, and the protection of pollinators

– the risks of phytotoxicity and leaf burn during periods of high heat

Antonin also highlighted the limitations: fatigue, practical implementation, and the risk of dilution due to dew on the plants.

 

Alternatives to copper: current situation, existing and future solutions

Various solutions were presented:

– Use of natural preparations of low concern (PNPP)

– Mineral spray solutions (Macab, AVAM Bio)

– Developments in plant material and the advent of new genomic techniques (NTG)

– The VitiTunnel

As regards PNPPs, these products will help to reduce the use of copper whilst also improving its effectiveness. These preparations, which are often plant-based, can be used at different times:

– Horsetail, which is applied to the soil on its own at Easter to reduce the risk of downy mildew outbreaks at the start of the season by limiting the primary inoculum.

– Foliar application of dandelion, willow or meadowsweet, which contain salicylic acid, a signal molecule.

– Foliar application of essential oils, such as oregano, or oak bark extracts, which contain polyphenols that have an antifungal effect.

Ideally, these products should be applied as standalone sprays; in practice, however, they are often applied in combination during treatment.

The solution presented by AVAM Bio, Macab, has also been used. This zeolite-based product – zeolite being a natural mineral of volcanic origin – acts as a physical barrier against downy mildew, with a residual effect on the foliage similar to that of copper. This product is to be applied on its own and is intended to replace copper. This physical barrier thus appears to have a dual effect:

– protection against downy mildew

– protection against heat

The product is currently awaiting approval for use in organic farming and is not authorised as a plant protection product. It was also emphasised that the product must not be applied in combination with wettable sulphur products, due to the risk of phytotoxicity (adjuvant-related issues).

 

Resistant varieties, such as Voltis, which forms part of the RESDUR 1 programme, were also discussed. These new grape varieties are obtained through successive cross-breeding and selection for desirable traits (notably resistance to fungal diseases such as downy mildew and powdery mildew). The lengthy development time, disappointing organoleptic results (taste quality of the grapes, and consequently of the resulting wine), as well as the conditions for establishment within the Champagne AOC mean that their introduction into vineyards is slow and limited.

Genetic engineering (GE) technology was also discussed, following its adoption by the European Parliament on 17 June. These new grape varieties could thus contain genes conferring disease resistance, as well as characteristics that improve their tolerance to extreme weather conditions without altering the genetic material or its fundamental characteristics (notably the organoleptic parameters). Currently, the organic sector is opposed to their introduction. However, Antonin raised one concern:

If this solution becomes more widespread in the future, how can we explain why organic farmers are opposed to it, given that it helps, in particular, to limit the use of plant protection products?

 

The Viti Tunnel solution was also presented. The main drawback of the technology at present is its cost: around €500,000 per hectare. The system and how it works were therefore demonstrated, along with the technology’s many potential benefits:

– protection against frost

– protection against hail

– protection of plant material against adverse weather conditions, and thus a drastic reduction in the use of plant protection products (as powdery mildew may require treatment).

– the option to provide shade, helping to lower the temperature of the vines and thus limit the potential risks of sunscald or leaf burn.

– an automated system, powered by batteries and solar energy.

The system is currently being trialled at the Plumecoq experimental vineyard, as well as on an organic estate near Reims. It is not authorised under AOC regulations and, for the time being, can only be installed on an experimental basis (in order to retain the AOC status for the production).

Did you like this post ? Share it :